What are major arguments for job analysis?
Explore the purpose and evolution job design, the role of effective job design in creating good work, and assessing job quality Show
On this pageOn this pageIntroductionJob design is the process of establishing employees’ roles and responsibilities and the systems and procedures that they should use or follow. The main purpose of job design, or redesign, is to coordinate and optimise work processes to create value and maximise performance. However, it’s also a central element in creating good quality jobs or ‘good work’ which benefit workers themselves as well as their employers. This factsheet examines job design and its links to work motivation, empowerment and job quality. It looks at the principles of job design, the role of job analysis and how assessing job quality can help. Job design, or redesign, is a process of determining job roles and what a job involves, as well as how it relates to other relevant jobs and the organisation’s structure. It includes deciding on the duties and responsibilities of the job holder, the way the job is done, as well as what support and resources the job holder needs. It can be done stringently or flexibly, depending on the nature and scope of the work that needs to be done. The main purpose of job design is to optimise work processes, ensure the right value is created and improve productivity. It does this by clarifying roles, systems and procedures; reducing repetitive elements within and between jobs; and optimising the workers’ responsibility. However, these aspects of managing people are not only about the face-value effectiveness of allocating resources. They’re also closely linked to core employee attitudes and work behaviours, including motivation, commitment, discretionary effort and job satisfaction. These are enhanced through techniques such as job enlargement, job enrichment and job rotation. Job design is an important element of people strategy as it influences:
Job design is thus a central component of job quality or ‘good work’ that benefits those doing the job as well as the organisation's long-term growth and sustainability. The objectives of job design will vary according to business demands and the organisation’s approach. However, the following will feature to some extent in deciding both the approach and desired outcomes.
As we discuss in the next section, the emphasis in job design has seen important developments in the history of management, evolving to be much more person-centred. TaylorismThe idea of job design started in the industrial revolution. In the early 1900s, Taylor’s ‘scientific management’ principles were used to measure and sequence human inputs alongside machinery to achieve higher efficiencies. Two important concepts emerged:
In principle, Taylorism could involve varying tasks through job rotation to improve work experience. But above all, it was a mechanistic approach to job design that primarily served short-term productivity and efficiency, limiting worker autonomy as far as possible and making little effort to enhance people’s working lives. Nonetheless, it’s an important stage in the history of job analysis and design that can still be influential today. Self-determination and job characteristicsWith the rise of theories of motivation, behavioural considerations were integrated more firmly into job design, taking into account employee need for job satisfaction and flourishing. As we discuss in our evidence review which looks at work motivation, one of the most influential is self-determination theory, developed by Deci and Ryan in the 1970s and 1980s. This describes three areas of fundamental human needs that should be fulfilled in our work:
Hackman and Oldham’s job characteristics theory has also been extremely influential. It covers much of the same ground but also adds other factors, now well established to drive work motivation, which can also be considered in job design. These include:
A more recent addition is the theory of job crafting, developed by Wrzesniewski and Dutton. This builds on the above theories to argue that workers themselves can take the initiative to tailor or redesign their jobs to suit their preferences. Irrespective of how management sets up a job, employees can take some ownership of shaping the tasks they do, their work relationships and how they think about and find meaning in their work. High-performance work practicesJob design is central to theories of high-performance work practices (HPWP), or clusters of these into high-performance work systems (HPWS). These broadly align with self-determination theory, presenting a mutual gains view of people management based on the ‘AMO’ model:
Our research report Over-skilled and underused: investigating the untapped potential of UK skills, points to substantial untapped talent. In our survey, more than one third of UK employees had the skills to cope with more demanding duties than their current job needed. The views of workers themselves suggest that being under-skilled for one’s job is also a problem. Thus, the HPWS model proposes that effective recruitment and selection practices, and ongoing training and development are also important in supporting high performance. Flexible workingAnother aspect of job design concerns when and how much people work. These decisions can be driven by employers, for example through the use of temporary and zero-hours contracts, or by employees themselves, through flexible working arrangements that allow them to shape their working hours and achieve greater work-life balance. Job design should rely on careful job analysis – gathering information about the required outputs, the work needed to achieve them job, and the skills, resources and autonomy that will enable it. Job analysis should be informed by external and organisational factors as well as human, motivational and growth factors. External factors include:
Organisational factors include:
Human factors include:
Motivation and growth factors include:
The job analysis should form the basis of a job description and person specification or job profile. It’s important to measure job quality so employers can understand the strengths and weaknesses of the jobs in their organisations and how they can improve them. Employee surveys are a common way to gather such data. Our Good Work Index captures data on what we define as the seven dimensions of good work. One of these dimensions is job design and the nature of work. Within this, the index covers skills, workload, empowerment and meaning. The survey includes questions on:
Employers can use the questions from our Good Work Index survey and benchmark their results against our data from the UK. Books and reportsGRANT, A.M., FRIED, Y, and JUILLERAT, T. (2011). Work matters: job design in classic and contemporary perspectives. In ZEDECK, E. APA handbook of industrial and organizational psychology: Vol 1: Building and developing the organization. Washington DC: American Psychological Association. SPREITZER, G. (2008) ‘Taking stock: a review of more than twenty years of research on empowerment at work’ in BARLING, J. and COOPER, C. (eds). The SAGE handbook of organizational behaviour: Volume one: micro approaches. London: Sage Publications. TAMKIN, P., COWLING, M and HUNT, W. (2008) People and the bottom line. IES report 448. Brighton: Institute for Employment Studies. Journal articlesCGAGNÉ, M. and DECI, E. L. (2005) Self-determination theory and work motivation. Journal of Organizational Behavior. Vol 26, No 4. pp331-362. HACKMAN, J. R. (1980) Work redesign and motivation. Professional Psychology. Vol 11, No 3, pp445-455. KNIGHT, C. and PARKER, S.K. (2019) How work redesign interventions affect performance: an evidence-based model from a systematic review. Human Relations (online), 1 October. Reviewed in In a Nutshell, issue 91. SIMONS, R. (2005) Designing high-performance jobs. Harvard Business Review. Vol 83, No 7, July/August. pp55-62. TIMS, M., BAKKER, A.B. and DERKS, D. (2015) Job crafting and job performance: a longitudinal study. European Journal of Work & Organizational Psychology. December, Vol 24, No 6. pp914-928. WRZESNIEWSKI, A. and DUTTON, J. E. (2001) Crafting a job: revisioning employees as active crafters of their work. Academy of Management Review. Vol 26, No 2. pp179-201. CIPD members can use our online journals to find articles from over 300 journal titles relevant to HR. Members and People Management subscribers can see articles on the People Management website. Download factsheet This factsheet was last updated by Jonny Gifford. Jonny Gifford: Senior Adviser for Organisational BehaviourJonny is the CIPD’s Senior Adviser for Organisational Behaviour. He has had a varied career in researching employment and people management issues, working at the Institute for Employment Studies and Roffey Park Institute before joining the CIPD in 2012. A central focus in his work is applying behavioural science insights to core aspects of people management. Recently he has led programmes of work doing this in the areas of recruitment, reward and performance management. Jonny is also committed to helping HR practitioners make better use of evidence to make better decisions. He runs the CIPD Applied Research Conference, which exists to strengthen links between academic research and HR practice. What are the major aspects of job analysis?Job analysis is the process of studying a job to determine which activities and responsibilities it includes, its relative importance to other jobs, the qualifications necessary for performance of the job and the conditions under which the work is performed.
What are major criticisms of job analysis?There may be many other problems involved in a job analysis process such as insufficient time and resources, distortion from incumbent, lack of proper communication, improper questionnaires and other forms, absence of verification and review of job analysis process and lack of reward or recognition for providing ...
What are the main objectives of job analysis?The main purpose of conducting job analysis is to prepare job description and job specification which would help to hire skilled workforce. Job description is a statement of information about duties and responsibilities of a particular job.
What 3 elements should any job analysis include?There are three primary types of job analysis data:. Work activities: Data on the specific activities that make up a job.. Worker attributes: Data on the qualities that workers need to do the job.. Work context: Data on the internal and external environment of the job.. |